Different Characteristics and Development Trends of Marine Fishery Carbon Sink Research at Home and Abroad
-
摘要:
厘清国内外海洋渔业碳汇研究的发展方向与特点，对于实现“双碳”目标，落实绿色、低碳渔业发展理念具有重要的理论与实践价值。该研究使用文献计量分析法并与系统性综述相结合，解析国内外海洋渔业碳汇研究的特色与发展趋势；以Web of Science（WOS）和中国知网（CNKI）数据库有关文献为数据基础，借助Citespace可视化技术分析21世纪以来（2001―2022年）国内外海洋渔业碳汇研究发展的热点、主要研究方向及总体进展，得到5方面研究结果。①通过关键词聚类分析，发现“碳汇渔业”“碳循环”和“海洋碳汇”3个研究方向是居于前3位的主导领域。②国际学术刊物中渔业碳汇（2020年开始）和生态系统服务（2022年开始）等已成为近年突现性较高的关键词，这表明国际上对海洋生态系统的服务性及其与人类关系的研究正在逐步加强。③过去20年间，美国在海洋渔业碳汇领域发文量最多，并且中介中心性最大；德国、英国和澳大利亚的研究机构也有较多研究成果；中国的论文增长率较高，总体上居于美国、英国、德国和澳大利亚之后。④国内外在海洋渔业碳汇研究中的重点既有同一性，也有差异性；我国的主要研究方向集中在海洋碳汇作用机理研究、海洋碳汇效应分析、海洋碳汇增汇技术和海洋碳捕集利用与封存技术等方面；国际上更关注海洋生态系统演变及其对人类的影响。⑤近年来，海洋碳汇核算、海洋碳汇实物量计量分析及海洋碳汇价值量计算等愈发受到重视；同时，对碳汇渔业的养殖机理、发展模式、市场构建和激励措施等研究，增长趋势明显。
Abstract:It is significant to clarify development directions and characteristics of marine fishery carbon sink research at home and abroad, which is of theoretical and practical value for China to learn from international experience and achieve "carbon peaking and carbon neutrality" goals and concept of green, low-carbon fishery industry development．Domestic and foreign characteristics and development trends of marine fishery carbon sink research were analyzed with help of bibliometric analysis and systematic review method．Using Citespace visualization technology, hot spots, main research directions and general progress of domestic and foreign marine fishery carbon sink research development since the beginning of the 21st century（2001―2022）were analyzed．Data from Web of Science（WOS）and China National Knowledge Internet（CNKI）were baselines．Firstly, "carbon sink fishery", "carbon cycle" and "ocean carbon sink" were identified to be top three dominant areas through keyword clustering analysis．Secondly, fishery carbon sink（from 2020）and ecosystem services（from 2022）have become highly visible keywords in international academic journals recently, indicating that international research on serviceability of marine ecosystems and their relationship with humans were gradually increasing．Thirdly, during the past 20 years, America has published the most articles in field of marine fishery carbon sink and has the largest betweenness centrality．Research institutions in Germany, Britain and Australia also have brilliant research results．China has a remarkable growth rate of articles and is keeping catching up with and surpass advanced levels．Fourthly, there are both similarities and differences in the focus of domestic and international research on marine fishery carbon sink．The main directions of China's research on marine fishery carbon sink were focused on: principles of marine carbon sink, analysis of effect of marine carbon sink, marine carbon sink enhancement technology and marine carbon collection and utilization and storage technology．However, other countries focued more on evolution of marine ecosystems and their impacts on humans．Fifthly, accounts on marine carbon sink, metrological analysis of physical quantity of marine carbon sink and calculation of marine carbon sink value have received more and more attention．In the meantime, research on breeding mechanism, development model, market construction and incentives of fishery carbon sink has been on upward trend noticeably．
-
图 1 2001―2022年WOS数据库海洋渔业碳汇研究发文数量
Figure 1. Number of articles published on marine fishery carbon sink research in WOS database from 2001 to 2022
图 2 2001―2022年CNKI数据库海洋渔业碳汇研究发文数量
Figure 2. Number of articles published on marine fishery carbon sink research in CNKI database from 2001 to 2022
图 5 WOS中主要国家/地区关系图谱
Figure 5. Knowledge graph of relations of countries/regions in WOS
图 6 WOS中发文作者及合作关系图谱
Figure 6. Knowledge graph of main authors and cooperative relations in WOS
图 7 CNKI中主要发文作者及合作关系图谱
Figure 7. Knowledge graph of main authors and cooperative relations in CNKI
图 8 CNKI中主要研究机构及合作关系图谱
Figure 8. Knowledge graph of main research institutions and cooperative relations in CNKI
表 1 WOS中频次前10的关键词
Table 1. Top 10 keywords in frequency in WOS
排名 关键词 词频 1 blue carbon（蓝碳） 61 2 marine snow（海洋雪） 39 3 ocean（海洋） 37 3 climate change（气候变化） 37 5 phytoplankton（浮游藻或植物性浮游生物） 26 6 carbon（碳） 24 7 organic matter（生物质） 23 8 dynamics（动力学） 22 8 organic carbon（有机碳） 22 10 marine（渔业生产） 20 10 carbon sink（碳汇） 20 
下载: 导出CSV
表 2 WOS中中介中心性前10的关键词
Table 2. Top 10 keywords in betweenness centrality in WOS
排名 关键词 中介中心性 1 ocean（海洋） 0.24 2 climate change（气候变化） 0.16 3 organic matter（生物质） 0.15 3 phytoplankton（浮游藻或植物性浮游生物） 0.15 5 marine（渔业生产） 0.14 5 marine snow（海洋雪） 0.14 7 blue carbon（蓝碳） 0.13 8 dissolved organic matter（溶解性有机物） 0.11 8 dynamics（动力学） 0.11 10 CO2（二氧化碳） 0.09 10 growth（生长） 0.09 10 marine sediment（海洋沉积物） 0.09 10 matter（物质） 0.09 10 carbon（碳） 0.09
下载: 导出CSV
表 3 CNKI中频次前10的关键词
Table 3. Top 10 keywords in frequency in CNKI
排名 关键词 词频 1 蓝碳 29 2 碳汇 27 3 碳汇渔业 21 3 海洋碳汇 21 5 碳中和 17 6 红树林 15 7 海水养殖 14 7 大型藻类 14 9 气候变化 11 9 碳循环 11
下载: 导出CSV
表 4 CNKI中中介中心性前10的关键词
Table 4. Top 10 keywords in betweenness centrality in CNKI
排名 关键词 中介中心性 1 海洋 0.55 2 气候变化 0.42 3 碳汇渔业 0.41 4 红树林 0.34 4 浮游植物 0.34 6 海洋碳汇 0.32 7 大型藻类 0.29 8 海水养殖 0.27 9 碳循环 0.26 9 低碳经济 0.26 9 水产养殖 0.26
下载: 导出CSV
表 5 WOS中发文量前10位的国家
Table 5. Top 10 countries in number of published articles in WOS
排名 国家 发文量 中介中心性 1 美国 91 0.46 2 英国 51 0.27 3 德国 48 0.09 4 澳大利亚 41 0.38 5 中国 33 0.02 6 法国 29 0.10 7 加拿大 26 0.27 8 挪威 22 0.14 9 西班牙 20 0.09 10 丹麦 14 0.01
下载: 导出CSV
表 6 WOS中发文量前5位的作者
Table 6. Top 5 authors in number of published articles in WOS
排名 作者 发文量 1 IVERSEN M H 9 2 BARNES D K A 7 3 SANDERS R. 6 4 BIDLE K D 5 4 CAVAN E L 5
下载: 导出CSV
表 7 CNKI中发文量前10位的作者
Table 7. Top 10 authors in number of published articles in CNKI
排名 作者 发文量 1 刘纪化 12 2 方建光 10 2 张继红 10 4 唐启升 9 5 蒋增杰 8 6 岳冬冬 7 6 焦念志 7 6 权伟 7 6 应苗苗 7 6 周庆澔 7
下载: 导出CSV
表 8 WOS中发文量5篇以上的研究机构
Table 8. Research institutions with more than 5 published articles in WOS
排名 研究机构 国家 发文量 1 Alfred Wegener Institute for Polar and Marine Research 德国 16 2 National Oceanography Centre 英国 12 2 Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution 美国 12 4 Universität Bremen 德国 10 5 University of California, Santa Barbara 美国 9 5 University of Southampton 英国 9 7 Chinese Academy of Sciences 中国 8 8 GEOMAR Helmholtz-Zentrum für Ozeanforschung Kiel 德国 7 8 University of Tasmania 澳大
利亚7 10 Technical University of Denmark 丹麦 6 10 Washington University 美国 6
下载: 导出CSV
表 9 CNKI中发文量5篇以上的研究机构
Table 9. Research institutions with more than 5 published articles in CNKI
排名 研究机构 发文量 1 中国水产科学研究院黄海水产研究所 22 2 中国海洋大学经济学院 15 3 山东大学海洋研究院 14 4 青岛海洋科学与技术试点国家实验室 12 5 中国科学院南海海洋研究所 8 5 中国海洋大学管理学院 8 7 中国水产科学研究院东海水产研究所 7 7 中国科学院海洋研究所 7 7 中国海洋大学海洋发展研究院 7 10 上海海洋大学水产与生命学院 6
下载: 导出CSV
-
[1] 彭天玥,唐得昊,刘丽强,等.基于专利分析的海洋碳封存技术[J].中国科学院院刊,2022,37(9): 1347 - 1359 .PENG Tianyue,TANG Dehao,LIU Liqiang,et al.Global technology of ocean carbon sequestration based on patent analysis[J].Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences,2022,37(9): 1347 - 1359 . [2] 郭波.中国海水贝藻养殖碳汇潜力的评估研究[J].现代农业科技,2015(19): 226 - 228 .GUO Bo.Study on assessment of carbon sequestration potential of marine shellfish culture in China[J].Modern Agricultural Science and Technology,2015(19): 226 - 228 . [3] 农业农村部.2021年全国渔业经济统计公报[EB/OL].(2022-07-21).http://www.yyj.moa.gov.cn/gzdt/202207/t20220721_6405222.htm. [4] 孙吉亭,赵玉杰.我国碳汇渔业发展模式研究[J].东岳论丛,2011,32(8): 150 - 155 . [5] 唐启升,蒋增杰,毛玉泽.渔业碳汇与碳汇渔业定义及其相关问题的辨析[J].渔业科学进展,2022,43(5): 1 - 7 .TANG Qisheng,JIANG Zengjie,MAO Yuze.Clarification on the definitions and its relevant issues of fisheries carbon sink and carbon sink fisheries[J].Progress in Fishery Sciences,2022,43(5): 1 - 7 . [6] 高磊,刘英杰.以科技创新引领低碳渔业发展:助推中国低碳发展的有效路径[J].科技管理研究,2011,31(23): 48 - 50 .GAO Lei,LIU Yingjie.Science and technology innovation leading the development of low-carbon fishery:an effective way to promote low-carbon development in China[J].Science and Technology Management Research,2011,31(23): 48 - 50 . [7] 谢素美,罗伍丽,贺义雄,等.中国海洋碳汇交易市场构建[J].科技导报,2021,39(24): 84 - 95 .XIE Sumei,LUO Wuli,HE Yixiong,et al.Construction of China's marine carbon sink trading market[J].Science & Technology Review,2021,39(24): 84 - 95 . [8] 赵云,乔岳,张立伟.海洋碳汇发展机制与交易模式探索[J].中国科学院院刊,2021,36(3): 288 - 295 .ZHAO Yun,QIAO Yue,ZHANG Liwei.Development mechanism and trading mode of marine carbon sink[J].Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences,2021,36(3): 288 - 295 . [9] 刘芳明,刘大海,郭贞利.海洋碳汇经济价值核算研究[J].海洋通报,2019,38(1): 8 - 13,19 .LIU Fangming,LIU Dahai,GUO Zhenli.Study on economic value accounting of ocean carbon sink[J].Marine Science Bulletin,2019,38(1): 8 - 13,19 . [10] 曹云梦,吴婧.“双碳”目标下我国海洋碳汇交易的发展机制研究[J].中国环境管理,2022,14(4): 44 - 51 .CAO Yunmeng,WU Jing.Research on the development mechanism of China's ocean carbon sink trading under the "dual-carbon" goal[J].Chinese Journal of Environmental Management,2022,14(4): 44 - 51 . [11] 纪丽娟.我国加快海洋蓝碳市场建设的路径选择[J].价格理论与实践,2021(11): 55 - 59 .JI Lijuan.China has accelerated the path choice of marine blue carbon market construction[J].Price:Theory & Practice,2021(11): 55 - 59 . [12] 程娜,陈成.海洋碳汇、碳税、绿色技术:实现“双碳”目标的组合策略研究[J].山东大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2021(6): 150 - 161 .CHENG Na,CHEN Cheng.Marine carbon sink,carbon tax,and green technology:a research on combination strategy to achieve "double carbon" goals[J].Journal of Shandong University (Philosophy and Social Sciences),2021(6): 150 - 161 . [13] 孙康,崔茜茜,苏子晓,等.中国海水养殖碳汇经济价值时空演化及影响因素分析[J].地理研究,2020,39(11): 2508 - 2520 .SUN Kang,CUI Xixi,SU Zixiao,et al.Spatio-temporal evolution and influencing factors of the economic value for mariculture carbon sinks in China[J].Geographical Research,2020,39(11): 2508 - 2520 . [14] 徐敬俊,覃恬恬,韩立民.海洋“碳汇渔业”研究述评[J].资源科学,2018,40(1): 161 - 172 .XU Jingjun,QIN Tiantian,HAN Limin.A review of research on marine carbon sink fisheries[J].Resources Science,2018,40(1): 161 - 172 . [15] KRAUSE-JENSEN D,DUARTE C M.Substantial role of macroalgae in marine carbon sequestration[J].Nature Geoscience,2016,9(10): 737 - 742 . doi: 10.1038/ngeo2790 [16] HMELO L R,MINCER T J,Van M B A S.Possible influence of bacterial quorum sensing on the hydrolysis of sinking particulate organic carbon in marine environments[J].Environmental microbiology reports,2011,3(6): 682 - 688 . doi: 10.1111/j.1758-2229.2011.00281.x [17] TAUCHER J,BACH L T,RIEBESELL U,et al.The viscosity effect on marine particle flux:a climate relevant feedback mechanism[J].Global Biogeochemical Cycles,2014,28(4): 415 - 422 . doi: 10.1002/2013GB004728 [18] HALFTER S,CAVAN E L,BUTTERWORTH P,et al."Sinking dead":how zooplankton carcasses contribute to particulate organic carbon flux in the subantarctic Southern Ocean[J].Limnology and Oceanography,2021,67(1): 13 - 25 . [19] 刘慧,唐启升.国际海洋生物碳汇研究进展[J].中国水产科学,2011,18(3): 695 - 702 .LIU Hui,TANG Qisheng.Review on worldwide study of ocean biological carbon sink[J].Journal of Fishery Sciences of China,2011,18(3): 695 - 702 . [20] 胡剑波,张强.低碳经济发展新思路:蓝色碳汇及中国对策[J].世界农业,2015(8): 43 - 47,87 . [21] 章海波,骆永明,刘兴华,等.海岸带蓝碳研究及其展望[J].中国科学:地球科学,2015,45(11): 1641 - 1648 . [22] 李捷,刘译蔓,孙辉,等.中国海岸带蓝碳现状分析[J].环境科学与技术,2019,42(10): 207 - 216 .LI Jie,LIU Yiman,SUN Hui,et al.Analysis of blue carbon in China's coastal zone[J].Environmental Science & Technology,2019,42(10): 207 - 216 . [23] 毛竹,陈虹,孙瑞钧,等.我国海洋碳汇建设现状、问题及建议[J].环境保护,2022,50(7): 50 - 53 .MAO Zhu,CHEN Hong,SUN Ruijun,et al.Analysis of marine carbon sink in China:current situation,problems and suggestions[J].Environmental Protection,2022,50(7): 50 - 53 . [24] 韩增林,李彬,张坤领,等.基于CiteSpace中国海洋经济研究的知识图谱分析[J].地理科学,2016,36(5): 643 - 652 .HAN Zenglin,LI Bin,ZHANG Kunling,et al.Knowledge structure of China's marine economy research:an analysis based on CiteSpace map[J].Scientia Geographica Sinica,2016,36(5): 643 - 652 . [25] 余菜花,廉同辉,刘军.中国低碳研究的知识图谱分析[J].资源科学,2012,34(10): 1959 - 1964 .YU Caihua,LIAN Tonghui,LIU Jun.An analysis of mapping knowledge domains of China's low-carbon research[J].Resources Science,2012,34(10): 1959 - 1964 . [26] 唐启升,刘慧.海洋渔业碳汇及其扩增战略[J].中国工程科学,2016,18(3): 68 - 73 . doi: 10.15302/J-SSCAE-2016.03.011TANG Qisheng,LIU Hui.Strategy for carbon sink and its amplifi cation in marine fisheries[J].Strategic Study of CAE,2016,18(3): 68 - 73 . doi: 10.15302/J-SSCAE-2016.03.011 [27] SHANKS A L.The abundance,vertical flux,and still-water and apparent sinking rates of marine snow in a shallow coastal water column[J].Continental Shelf Research,2002,22(14): 2045 - 2064 . doi: 10.1016/S0278-4343(02)00015-8 [28] INGRID I,PAOLO P,MARTIN P,et al.Seasonal variations in extracellular enzymatic activity in marine snow-associated microbial communities and their impact on the surrounding water[J].FEMS microbiology ecology,2018.https://doi.org/10.1093/femsec/fiy198. [29] GUTIERREZ T,TESKE A,ZIERVOGEL K,et al.Editorial:microbial exopolymers:sources,chemico-physiological properties,and ecosystem effects in the marine environment[J].Frontiers in microbiology,2018,9: 1822 . doi: 10.3389/fmicb.2018.01822 [30] 张继红,刘毅,吴文广,等.海洋渔业碳汇项目方法学探究[J].渔业科学进展,2022,43(5): 151 - 159 .ZHANG Jihong,LIU Yi,WU Wenguang,et al.Overview of the marine fishery carbon sink project methodology[J].Progress in Fishery Sciences,2022,43(5): 151 - 159 . [31] 贺义雄,王燕炜,谢素美,等.我国海洋碳汇研究进展:基于CNKI(2006―2021年)的文献分析[J].海洋经济,2022,12(4): 1 - 16 .HE Yixiong,WANG Yanwei,XIE Sumei,et al.Research progress of marine carbon sink in China:literature analysis based on CNKI (2006―2021)[J].Marine Economy,2022,12(4): 1 - 16 . [32] 张樨樨,郑珊,余粮红.中国海洋碳汇渔业绿色效率测度及其空间溢出效应[J].中国农村经济,2020(10): 91 - 110 .ZHANG Xixi,ZHENG Shan,YU Lianghong.Green efficiency measurement and spatial spillover effect of China’s marine carbon sequestration fishery[J].Chinese Rural Economy,2020(10): 91 - 110 . [33] 张波,唐启升.中国近海渔业生物捕捞群体碳汇评估[J].渔业科学进展,2022,43(5): 126 - 131 .ZHANG Bo,TANG Qisheng.Carbon sink assessment for capture stock in China coastal ocean[J].Progress in Fishery Sciences,2022,43(5): 126 - 131 . [34] 严立文,黄海军,陈纪涛,等.我国近海藻类养殖的碳汇强度估算[J].海洋科学进展,2011,29(4): 537 - 545 .YAN Liwen,HUANG Haijun,CHEN Jitao,et al.Estimation of carbon sink capacity of algal mariculture in the coastal areas of China[J].Advances in Marine Science,2011,29(4): 537 - 545 . [35] 叶旺旺,张麋鸣,孙恒,等.贝藻类养殖碳汇核算与综合温室潜力评估研究进展[J].应用海洋学学报,2022,41(4): 715 - 723 .YE Wangwang,ZHANG Miming,SUN Heng,et al.Progress in carbon sequestration estimation and comprehensive warming potential assessment in marine aquaculture of shellfish and seaweed[J].Journal of Applied Oceanography,2022,41(4): 715 - 723 . [36] 刘纪化,郑强.从海洋碳汇前沿理论到海洋负排放中国方案[J].中国科学:地球科学,2021,51(4): 644 - 652 . [37] 李娇,李梦迪,公丕海,等.海洋牧场渔业碳汇研究进展[J].渔业科学进展,2022,43(5): 142 - 150 .LI Jiao,LI Mengdi,GONG Pihai,et al.Research progress on fishery carbon sinking associated with marine ranching[J].Progress in Fishery Sciences,2022,43(5): 142 - 150 . [38] 唐启升,水产养殖业可持续发展战略研究课题组.水产养殖业可持续发展战略研究[J].中国家禽,2012,34(11): 13 - 15 . [39] 唐启升,丁晓明,刘世禄,等.我国水产养殖业绿色、可持续发展保障措施与政策建议[J].中国渔业经济,2014,32(2): 5 - 11 .TANG Qisheng,DING Xiaoming,LIU Shilu.Safeguard measures and policy recommendations for green and sustainable development of Chinese aquaculture[J].Chinese Fisheries Economics,2014,32(2): 5 - 11 . -
下载:
点击查看大图
计量
- 文章访问数: 25
- HTML全文浏览量: 17
- PDF下载量: 7
- 被引次数: 0
京公网安备 11010502037498号
